Simply food


Home-made Melton Mowbray-style pork pie

Home-made Melton Mowbray-style pork pie

RECIPE: Authentic Melton Mowbray pork pie.

FOOD AND TRAVEL DIARY: Nigel scours middle England for a perfect pork pie.

One tasty morsel you can hardly find in North America is a decent pork pie. I’m not talking any old pork pie, but one filled with succulent chopped pork meat, not too fatty, not too lean, and a delicious jellied pork stock, in a thickly crusted pastry. As soon as we arrive in England for one of our regular visits, we head to a good food shop, usually Marks & Spencer or Sainsbury, and buy a pork pie. Traditionally served cold, with some tangy Branston pickle or chutney on the side, this is often our first picnic style meal, eaten on the run, while we are unpacking at our little South Yorkshire cottage.

The king of pork pies is the Melton Mowbray original and producers there have recently gone as far as registering their product with a Protected Designation of Origin status, like Champagne, or Parma ham. In the shops, a Melton Mowbray pie commands a premium price, and I’d say it’s worth it. The pies are slightly bowed out at the sides, which comes from being baked without a mold, and particularly delicious inside.

Home of the authentic Melton Mowbray pork pie

Home of the authentic Melton Mowbray pork pie

Over our first few days, I sample pies from both the top food chains mentioned earlier. They’re good pies. But the pork is minced, not chopped, and the casings are clearly factory, not hand, made. So on a long trip back from the south of England, driving north on the M1 motorway, just north of the county town of Leicester, I spot a road sign to Melton Mowbray. On a whim we turn off the main highway and head east. We pass through little villages on a winding minor road, with signposts to quaintly named places such as Barrow-upon-Soar, Burrough-on-the-hill and Frisby-on-the-Wreake. On the outskirts of Melton Mowbray, Diane asks innocently enough, how we are going to find a pie shop, and it’s a good question because I haven’t done any research, and have no idea. I’m just about to admit that when I spot a sign to Ye Olde Pork Pie Shoppe, and then another. We park and it’s an easy walk through the busy market day stalls to the shoppe. How clever of them to know we were coming.

M&S (L) and Sainsbury's (R) pork pies at the cottage

M&S (L) and Sainsbury’s (R) pork pies at the cottage

In we go, buy an authentic hand-made pie, and ask for the recipe, which they decline to share. They point to a wall of photographs of the pies being made on the premises, which I study. It’s late in the afternoon and most of the pies have gone, so as they seem keen to close up shop, we head out without further questions. On the way back to the car, at another butcher’s shop, offering a different brand of equally authentic pies, I spot a series of curious wooden forms. They’re round, like half of a short, fat rolling pin. The friendly butcher sells me a small one, suitable for making an approximately one pound pie. He warns me that the pie is easy to make but the secret is in the pastry. The dollies, as he calls them, are all out of date, which is why they are cheap, EU rules having forced metric measurements even on Melton Mowbray pies. I treasure my dolly all the way back to Canada, where she will be put to good use.

An authentic Melton Mowbray pork pie in the bluebell woods, posing with my new dolly

An authentic Melton Mowbray pork pie in the bluebell woods, posing with my new dolly

Meanwhile, the woods are full of carpets of bluebells, as we head the 50 miles to home. Feeling a bit peckish, we stop for an impromptu picnic, lay a blanket in the cool shade and devour our pie. It never makes it home. And it is truly an outstanding pie. The pastry is a wonderful, slightly lardy texture, the filling simple and tasty. The mighty Corsa delivers us home with full bellies.

Secrets on the photo display at Dickinson & Morris

Secrets on the photo display at Dickinson & Morris

Mission accomplished, I’m intrigued by the history of the pie and why this little town in the middle of England should become so famous for such a singular product. It turns out that over the centuries, the Melton Mowbray area has become equally famous for Stilton cheese. The development of the dairy industry was largely a result of land being enclosed by wealthy landowners in the 1700s, which coincidentally also produced a perfect landscape for fox hunting by the gentry, while the serfs milked the cows. Whey is a by-product of cheese making and is perfect food for pigs, so pork became a big part of the local diet.

Agricultural workers would take a parcel of pastry wrapped around a pork filling for their lunch, discarding the pastry before eating. Three famous local hunts —  Quorn, Cottesmore and Belvior (which we all know is pronounce ‘beaver’) – made Melton the capital of fox hunting and visiting hunters discovered the local pies when they saw grooms and hunt servants eating them. By then the pastry had been made edible, and the pies filled with jelly to prevent them collapsing during the rough ride during the chase. Ye Olde Pork Pie Shoppe is run by butchers Dickinson and Morris, founded in 1851. It is the oldest bakery and last one to actually make their pies in Melton Mowbray. I was sorry not to have been able to watch one of their demos, but the photographs on the wall gave me a few hints on how to form the pastry round the dolly.

Dolly-formed home-made pork pies ready for the oven

Dolly-formed home-made pork pies ready for the oven

Back in Canada, with an idle couple of days ahead of me between other assignments and chores, I decide to tackle the production of a couple of pies. First, I head down to the St. Lawrence Market where Pat Gasparro, my favourite butcher at Brown Brothers, cuts me off the requisite amount of fatty pork shoulder and lean loin. The two different meats are essential to make the filling just right. Too much of one and it will be too fatty, of the other too dry. The Melton Mowbray recipe calls for fresh pork, not smoked, like ham. The resulting filling, when cooked, will be grey, like a roast pork, rather than pink. I ask him for some bones, to make my stock and jelly, and he sells me a big bag for a buck. I promise him a pie if it turns out well.

Step one is to make the stock and let it set into a jelly. This is an overnight process. The pastry also needs to rest in the fridge overnight. Then I make my pies, the pastry is like play dough and easy to handle. The thick disk is hand raised up the dolly and then carefully removed. This was a tricky part, but by the second pie I had the hang of it. Using a measuring scale, I weigh out the requisite amount of filling and roll it into a ball, then drop it into the casing. A lick of beaten egg helps the lid seal onto the sides. To make the pie authentic, I scallop the edge with my thumb and fingers. It looks good so far. Then they have to sit another night in the fridge. Finally, I bake them, allow them to cool, fill them with the stock and put them in the fridge to set, another day gone by. By the fourth day, we’re taste-testing them. My word, they’re really good. I might have cooked them a little long in a too hot oven, so the pastry is a little dry, but otherwise they’re delicious. We down the pies in no time at all. Pat will have to wait for his free sample until I make another batch.

PS: Since writing this article in the spring of 2014, I notice the newly renovated local Loblaws supermarket in Toronto is offering what they call Melton Mowbray Pork Pie. They’re locally made, claims the butcher, and I expect he doesn’t know he’s violating the naming rules. Oh well, we are in the colonies. The taste test does not go well. It’s a pork pie all right, but made with smoked pork, not in the genuine Melton Mowbray style at all. It could have made the summer of 2015 profound. Black mark to Loblaw.


  • Servings: 2
  • Print
Author: Stephen Hallam, Dickenson & Morris
Prep time: 60 mins
Cook time: 90 mins
Total time: 2 hours 30 mins
These are the steps to making a single approximately 1lb (1/2 kg) pie. But its easier to make a batch of at least two. It takes patience over several days to finish.
  • 113 g cake and pastry flour (all purpose in US)
  • pinch of salt
  • 50 g lard
  • 30 ml water
  • beaten egg for glazing


  • 110g pork shoulder chopped into 5cm pieces
  • 110 g pork loin chopped into 5cm pieces
  • salt and pepper
  • 125 ml pork stock


Make the pastry

  1. Sift flour and salt together in a bowl, cut up 15 g lard into small pieces and rub in until the mixture is like sand.
  2. Gently heat the remaining lard and water together until boiling, then add to the flour and stir with a spoon until the mixture is cool enough to knead by hand.
  3. Knead well. Roll into a ball, cover with cling film and leave in the fridge overnight.

Raise the pie

Day 2:

  1. Remove the pastry from the fridge two hours before making the pie case. Gently squeeze the pastry until it becomes pliable. Cut off a quarter portion to serve as the lid.
  2. Make a thick disk of pastry and place your dolly in the middle. (If you do not have a dolly and clean, washed and empty round jam jar will do quite well.) The dolly should be well dusted with flour to prevent the pastry sticking. Using your hands, carefully mould the pastry up and around the form ensuring the sides are of equal thickness all round. It is crucial that there be no weak spots or holes in the pastry.
  3. Carefully remove the pastry case from the form.

The filling

  1. Using equal portions of fatty pork shoulder and lean pork loin, chop the fresh meat into small cubes.
  2. Season well, especially with pepper, and mix the two meats together in a bowl.
  3. Make it into a ball.


  1. Put the ball of filling in the pie case. There should be some room left over.
  2. Roll out the reserved piece of pastry into a round lid, dampen the rim of the pastry case with beaten egg and press the lid firmly onto the top.
  3. Using fingers and thumb, make a decorative crimp around the edge.
  4. Brush the top of the pie with beaten egg, not the edge, and make a hole in the centre for steam to escape during baking.
  5. Cover the pie and chill thoroughly, preferably overnight.


Day 3:

  1. Heat the oven to 200°C (390°F).
  2. Put the pie on a sheet of baking parchment and bake for 90 mins. If necessary, turn the oven down to 175°C (350°F) during the last 30 mins, to avoid browning the pastry too much.
  3. When baked, remove from the oven to a cooling rack and allow to cool.


  1. Using jellied pork stock you have prepared in advance, or by dissolving pork gelatin in pork stock, warm the jelly so it is liquid.
  2. When the pie has cooled somewhat, so you can handle it, make two holes in the lid. Pour in the warm stock, until it comes to the top of the pie. Depending on how much pork filling you used, you may not need all the stock, which can be reserved for next time.
  3. Place the pie back in the fridge overnight and enjoy cold on Day 4.
Pork pie dollies for sale in Melton Mowbray

Pork pie dollies for sale in Melton Mowbray


Home-made pork stock will jellify in the fridge
  • 900 g pork bones, with a little meat left on
  • 2 pig’s trotters, washed and split in half (by the butcher)
  • 2 large carrots, roughly chopped
  • 1 onion, roughly chopped
  • 1 bay leaf
  • 2 sprigs thyme
  • 6 sage leaves
  • 2 tsp crushed black peppercorns
  • 1 tsp coarse sea salt
  • 4 L water
  1. Place all the ingredients in a large saucepan and cover with as much of the water as needed. Bring slowly to the boil, then reduce to simmer.
  2. Simmer for three hours as low heat as possible, with the lid to aid evaporation, skimming off any impurities which rise to the surface.
  3. After three hours drain the liquid through a colander into another saucepan. Discard the solids, rinse out the first pan, and pour the stock through a fine sieve, to further purify it.
  4. Place a muslin cloth over the rinsed second pan, and pour the stock through the muslin to remove the last remnants of the solids. This will make the jelly clear when set.
  5. Simmer this stock over a medium heat until more liquid has evaporated and about 500 ml (2 cups) remains.
  6. Place in a covered container and into the fridge to set or until needed. Before using, scrape off and discard the white fat that will have risen to the top. The stock can be frozen and used later for home-made soups. It will be enough clear stock for several pork pies.

6 replies »

    • I’m glad you asked this question because when I went to review my blog I found that some of the photographs hadn’t loaded correctly. That issue has now been fixed and you will see there are pictures of the dollies on display in the shop where I bought them. The dolly size I bought is marked “to make an approximate 1 lb pie” and was on sale because EU rules now insist measures are in metric. It measures 2 3/4 inches in diameter and 3 7/8″ high.


  1. Truly interesting article on my beloved Melton Mowbray Pork Pies! Having been born and brought up in Leicestershire I can honestly say I have tried pies from all the producers who can legally make them and call them ‘Melton Mowbray’ pies. I have my favourites – indeed I have a league table! Having lived in the South of England due to work for the last thirty years I only get my ‘fix’ when I go up to see family. So something had to be done to make my own to mimic the original precisely. After several and ongoing trials I think I cracked it!!! The recipe given above is a great starting point BUT the pastry is improved by using strong bread flour instead of all purpose and by adding just a quarter of a tablespoon of icing sugar to the mix! All my research suggests that the meat should be ALL pork shoulder – keeps the pie moist. Additionally 5cm chunks of meat are far too big – about a third should be finely chopped and the rest should be max 1cm pieces. Again some would say that the stock should be made purely from boiled pigs trotters – I have done it and it works well. I have found that the best cooking time is 15 mins at 200oC then 1 hour at 180oC. I made my pork pie dollies from the correct diameter wooden rolling pin! Just cut one in half and you have two for the price of one.
    Hop[e this is of interest/help to anyone who wants to give it a go! Cheers.John


    • I’ve been able to find a few fake MM pies in Canada, but nothing like the real thing, which led to making my own. Your improvements sound like a good idea. Thanks for the tips.


  2. We spend a lot of time in France where pork pies are unheard of! I saw your recipe and bought myself a pork pie dolly from Melton Mowbray and have been baking pork pies since then. I bring lard to France (in my hand luggage to the consternation of the security people!) as the French equivalent ‘saindoux’ is too soft and the pastry doesn’t work. Like your previous correspondent, John, I find that fine chopping of shoulder pork is best. The pies need the fat from the shoulder pork for moistness. Most of my friends prefer not to have jelly in the pies, but I season them quite heavily. I’ve found a pinch of chilli powder, or some chopped sage works well. I also add finely chopped garlic and shallots. The last lot I did I took the meat out if some merguez sausages for about a third of the filling. The oil from the merguez meat leaked out a bit, but still delicious! Thank you for your recipe and your blog! Keep up the good work. Bon Appétit! And kind regards, Liz


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.