Simply food


Mushroom 1

Portobello mushrooms on the built-in grill

RECIPE: Eggs Portobello, a new take on eggs, bacon and mushrooms, not your usual full English breakfast.

DIARY: A feudal jewel of an island in the English Channel.

As an adult, and a confirmed city dweller, I’ve never dared venture out into the country to pick fresh mushrooms. It’s too easy to pick something poisonous and it’s too easy to get fresh ones at the supermarket. But the field mushrooms remembered from childhood seem to have had a flavour all their own.

On the tiny island of Sark, in the English Channel Islands, I spent idyllic Easter and summer holidays. The first time we went there as a family was one of the most wonderful summers in memory. It was 1956, and my mother, sister and I had been evacuated from Cairo, where there was some unpleasantness going on over the Suez Canal. How we quite ended up in Sark I don’t recall, but I think my folks knew someone there. Anyway, Mum phoned the Dame of Sark and asked for a recommendation for a hotel and the Dame (she was the last feudal ruler left in the British Isles) suggested Stocks Hotel, so that’s where we went. The owners became friends and on subsequent holidays, they kindly took me in and I stayed at Stocks alone. Later as a young adult I went to the island on camping trips.

Portobellos on the built-in grill

In the kitchen at Stocks there was always a welcome for a hungry lad, and indeed that’s probably where my love of cooking started. Old Granny Falle was the cook and would beckon me over to the stove to taste whatever she was making. Her daughter Sheila ran front of house, dad Charles ran the pub and their daughter Rosemary and I and a bunch of other teens ran wild. As I grew older, I started to help out in the hotel. First, washing up (a horrible chore which I despise to this day), then bussing big trays of plated breakfasts, lunches and dinners to the guests in the dining room, and bussing back the dirty dishes, and finally helping in the bar.

The Queen visits Sark in 1957 - still the best way to get around on the car-less island

The Queen visits Sark in 1957 – still the best way to get around on the car-less island

Occasionally, there were farm duties, for the hotel had cows for fresh milk, cream and butter, pigs for fresh chops, bacon and roasts, fields for potatoes and root veggies and a kitchen garden for greens and herbs. My duties usually involved shovelling manure. Fishermen brought in the fresh catch of the day, lobsters in season and the delicious ormers (abalone) for which the islands are noted. These could only be harvested at very low tides and even then were a rare delicacy. Now, due to overharvesting, they are almost all gone and the catch highly restricted. On calm days the fishermen would take a few of us out to haul in the lobster pots with side trips to explore Sark’s many caves.

In the early mornings after an overnight rain, Gran would pass the preparation of breakfast over to a helper and invite me to join her in a hunt for field mushrooms. She knew the secret spots where they grew, and which ones were safe to eat. The reward for helping to pick and carry the treasures back to the kitchen was a full English breakfast, with a whole fried mushroom as the special treat. The cap had a distinct flavour, earthy perhaps, and a texture not unlike a very fine steak. Heaven for a hungry teenager.

We missed the Queen’s visit in 1957, but Charlie the coachman was still getting free beers for retelling the story of her riding in his coach years later. Horse drawn coach, tractor or bicycle are still the only way to get around on the blissfully car-less island. I last visited Sark in the mid sixties, before washing up on North American shores, and have never returned, but as soon as I start cooking a big Portobello, I’m transported back to the Stocks Hotel kitchen.

So get the grill heated up and let’s cook these guys. We’ll serve up a new take on the traditional full English breakfast. Scrambled eggs go exceptionally well with mushrooms, bacon is optional if your religion or diet prohibits, but stacking it up high allows one to leave out the fried bread, muffin or toast and cut back on the calories. In any event, the end results are delicious.


  • Servings: 4
  • Print

by Nigel Napier-Andrews

Grilled Portobello mushrooms served with steamed asparagus spears

Grilled Portobello mushrooms served with steamed asparagus spears


  • 4 Portobello mushroom caps
  • 1/4 cup olive oil
  • 8 eggs
  • 4 slices of streaky bacon
  • fresh basil leaves (about 2 stalks or 8 leaves)
  • Tabasco (optional)
  • Fresh ground black pepper
  • Butter or margarine
  • Asparagus or Broccolini stalks (optional)


  1. Leave the mushrooms out in the open air for about an hour before you start this meal. The skin of the cap will dry a little and will be easier to peel off.
  2. Slice the bacon into 1/4 in lardons and boil in water for 5 mins, then drain thoroughly, pat dry with a paper towel, and fry briskly until they are crisp. Set aside onto a paper towel to remove all excess fat.
  3. Remove the stalk from the mushrooms, peel the skin back from the edge and optionally scrape the black gills out with a teaspoon. Personally, I like to leave them, but they can stain the scrambled eggs later if you are not careful. Then put the caps into a bowl and pour over the olive oil until the caps absorb all the oil. Toss them around so there are no dry bits. Then grill them over a BBQ, or saute them in a cast iron frying pan. No extra oil should be needed. It will take about 5 mins a side until they are done. Set to drain on a paper towel, bottom side up, to release any excess oil.
  4. Break the eggs into a bowl and whisk to mix the whites and yolks. Add about 2 tbsp water, since the eggs are subject to evaporation during cooking. Optionally, shake in a few drops of Tabasco for an extra kick. Melt a dab of butter or margarine in a pan and cook over a medium heat, stirring occasionally, until the eggs scramble, about 3 or 4 mins. Don’t overcook them as they will continue to set after they are removed from the heat.
  5. Meanwhile, wash the basil leaves thoroughly and discard the stalks. Pat dry with a paper towel. Slice the leaves into thin ribbons, discarding the thick centre vein.
  6. Optionally, steam some well washed asparagus spears, or broccolini stalks, bottoms broken off, to serve alongside the grilled caps. About 8 mins from boiling in a vertical steamer.
  7. Plate by turning the caps inside upwards and spoon the eggs into the caps. Making sure no one is a vegetarian or has a religious objection to bacon, sprinkle some crispy bacon pieces on top and finally garnish with a good pinch of basil ribbons. Grind some black pepper over the top for taste and an extra garnish. With the salty bacon, this dish should not need extra salt.

Eggs Portobello 1

The paler scrambled eggs on the right are made with only 1/2 a yolk for Diane’s cholesterol reduced diet

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.